Dyke and karen rhoads, randy steidl and herb whitlock never got a search for the. When questioned about the 1986 murders of newlyweds dyke and karen rhoads, randy assumed the police were questioning many people in the area. It was mainly about the murders in july 6, 1986, of newlyweds dyke and karen rhoads and the wrongful convictions of the two men, randy steidl and herb whitlock. Jan 09, 2008 while herb whitlock and randy steidl today have the freedom they have sought for so long, dyke and karen still do not have the justice they deserve, her family said in a statement. May 04, 2005 whitlock awaits a ruling on whether he will be granted a new trial. Prosecutors convicted two local barflies, herb whitlock and his friend gordon randy steidl, solely on the word of two other local barflies whose astonishing accounts of separately having witnessed the butchery have changed many times over the years. The morning of july 6, 1986, dyke and karen rhoads were found murdered in their bedroom. Former isp commanders book explores rhoads case news. Herb whitlock, the other man wrongly convicted of the murders, was exonerated and freed in 2008 after nearly 21 years behind bars. Prisoner free after 2 decades in prison for paris murder. As raindrops hit and rolled down his face, herbert r.
His book about the investigation of the rhoads case is too. Two days later, all of a sudden randy steidl and herb whitlock. Mar 16, 2009 in partnership with the new mexico coalition to repeal the death penalty, exonoree randy steidl speaks to students at albuquerques del norte high school about his 17 years on death row, wed. The evidence against these to committing this crime is the knife found from the scene and the witness that saw randy at the scene.
In 1987, herbert whitlock and randy steidl were arrested and convicted, based. Former deathrow inmate steidl says hes still trying to. Mar 10, 2012 too politically sensitive by michale callahan. Herb whitlock university of illinois springfield uis. Randy steidl and herb whitlock were drug sellers and sold the rhoads some drugs and they never got paid police believe this was the motive for the crime. Too politically sensitive 2009 edition open library. An illinois jury believed what prosecutors and witnesses told them about the july 1986 killing of dyke and karen rhoads. Herb whitlock, left, walks out of the edgar county jail tuesday, jan. Jan 20, 2011 a few months later, the moratorium halted executions in illinois. How randy steidl became the face of capital punishment repeal. Former death row inmate presents tale of missteps by. Join facebook to connect with randy steidl and others you may know. Death row stories, i hope they dont pull any punches like you or the appellate prosecutors office have. Too politically sensitive author michale callahan launches.
Mystery witness saw herb whitlock covered with blood short time after murders post on. Paris residents randy steidl and herb whitlock were convicted of the murders the following year, but their guilt was ultimately called into question in 2000 by. His book exposes the wrongdoing perpetrated by law enforcement and prosecution in the convictions of herb whitlock and randy steidl. Gordon randy steidl was released from the illinois correctional center at danville on may 28, 2004, making him the eighteenth person to be exonerated and released after having been sentenced to death in illinois since 1977.
While herb whitlock and randy steidl today have the freedom they have sought for so long, dyke and karen still do not have the justice they deserve, her. He told police that he had been drinking with two locals randy steidl and herb whitlock the night of the incident and had passed out in the. Former state trooper encourages activism in illinois darien. Randy steidl and herb whitlock were acquaintances who would run into each other at the bars around paris, ill. I believe that the book you are referring to is called too politically sensitive by michale callahan. Gordon randy steidl, center on wrongful convictions. Since when is murder too politically sensitive book online at best prices in india on.
They are stabbed dozens of times and their house is set afire. Steidl spent 17 years in prison, including 12 on death row, and whitlock was sentenced to life in prison. Investigator seeks pardon in 1986 paris murders news. Wrongly convicted man wins settlement 26 years later illinois times. Michale wrote one of the most important books i have ever read, too politically sensitive.
In 1987, herbert whitlock and randy steidl were arrested and convicted, based on the testimony of two alcoholics, deborah reinbolt and darrell herrington. During the trial, two alcoholics, one of whom was also addicted to drugs, pointed their fingers at steidl, a 35yearold construction worker with several assault convictions, and herb whitlock. The defendant, gordon randy steidl steidl, and codefendant herbert whitlock whitlock were indicted for the murders of dyke and karen rhoads, by an. Randys story thanks to witness to innocence randy steidl was an average, hardworking guy from a small farming community in southern illinois. Mystery witness saw herb whitlock covered with blood short. Over the years, attorney general lisa madigan has also. Spinning the wrong way what really happened in paris. Wrongly convicted man wins settlement 26 years later. Paris residents randy steidl and herb whitlock were convicted of the murders the following year, but their guilt was ultimately called into question in 2000 by legal researchers and the cbs 48. Herb whitlock and gordon randy steidl spent 21 and 17 years respectively in prison before key witnesses recanted, important evidence was deemed unreliable, and they were released.
Two local men, randy steidl and herb whitlock, were convicted of. In 1986, karen and dyke rhoads were stabbed to death in the master bedroom of their downstate paris home, and the house was then set afire. Its gonna be an adjustment for him, steidl said tuesday in a telephone. Karen rhoads, murder, arson, randy steidl, herb whitlock, wrongful convictions, edgar county, pardons. Finally, randy steidl was released in 2004, followed by herb whitlock in 2008. State trooper uncovers police misconduct that leads to. Whitlock was not there to tell his side of the story that i wish to have heard. Randy s story thanks to witness to innocence randy steidl was an average, hardworking guy from a small farming community in southern illinois. Randy steidl was released in 2004 and herb whitlock was released in 2008. Nearly nine years after being freed from prison, where he served 17 years for a double murder in the downstate city of paris before being freed for lack of evidence, gordon randy steidl. May 30, 2012 a recipient of the 2011 defenders of the innocents award bestowed by the downstate illinois innocence project, callahan finally saw the day when randy steidl and herb whitlock were free men, released from prison after serving approximately 20 years of their lives for a crime they didnt commit. While herb whitlock and randy steidl today have the freedom they have sought for so long, dyke and karen still do not have the justice they deserve, her family said in a statement.
The following year, in may 2004, a federal judge ordered randy s release. July 6, 1986 dyke and karen rhoads are murdered in their paris, illinois, house sometime after midnight and before dawn. Michale callahan with randy steidl and herb whitlock at book signing. Within a year, two men were arrested and convicted of the crime. The defendant, gordon randy steidl steidl, and codefendant herbert whitlock whitlock were indicted for the murders of dyke and karen rhoads, by an edgar 842 county grand jury. Defendants motion for a change of venue was allowed and thereafter the court granted defendants motion to sever his case from that of whitlock. Last lawsuit in wrongful paris convictions settled news. On july 6, 1986, newlyweds dyke and karen rhoades were repeatedly stabbed and murdered and their home set on fire in paris, illinois. Dyke and karen rhoads, randy steidl and herb whitlock never got a search for the truth, only coverup and deceit from a state more concerned about image, money and politics. Brutally stabbed over fifty times, their house was set. Jun 20, 2011 state trooper uncovers police misconduct that leads to exoneration for convicted men. His book, too politically sensitive, provides a detailed account of what happened behind the scenes at isp.
Herb whitlock illinois innocence project university of illinois. Clutter was investigating serial killer tommy lynn sells for the 1986 murders of dyke and karen rhoads in paris, illinois, that led to two innocent men being framed for that murder, randy steidl and herb whitlock. Two local men with police records, randy steidl and herb whitlock. Protess was able to add a major contribution to randys case, nevertheless.
Nov 05, 20 two local men with police records, randy steidl and herb whitlock, were arrested, tried, and convicted of murderthe prosecutions theory being that they turned to violence when a drug deal with dyke rhoads went south. In 20, randy steidl steidl won a second the first in 2011 against the illinois state police multimilliondollar judgment in his case against the people who framed him and put him in prison. Dyke and karen rhoads, randy steidl and herb whitlock never got a search for the truth, only coverup and deceit from a state more concerned about image. Whitlock were convicted of the crime at separate jury trials in edgar county. Whitlock, then 41, was a parttime construction worker and smalltime drug dealer. Wrongly convicted man wins multimilliondollar judgment. Callahan is author of the 2009 true crime book, since when is murder too politically sensitive. See how a persistent cop fought the system to for an innocent mans freedom on cnns death row stories. After more than 26 years of fighting, randy steidl is ready to put the past. He invited cbss 48 hours to feature randys case on national television.
It also touched on other corupt aspects of edgar county and illinois as a whole. Randy received the death penalty, while herb received a life sentence. It is time for dyke and karen to get the justice they rightly deserve. Herb whitlock, the other man wrongly convicted of the murders, was. Cnn focuses on 1986 paris murders local news commercial. Randy steidl and herb whitlock, were arrested, tried, and convicted of murderthe prosecutions theory being that they turned to violence when a drug. He said he heard arguments, and saw the knife, bodies, and the blood.
Randy steidl and herb whitlock spent more than a decade behind bars for the deaths of newlyweds dyke and karen rhoads. As told by randy steidl essay example bestwritingservice. Former state trooper encourages activism in illinois. Whitlock when they went to the rhoadss house that july morning. Mar 12, 2020 on september 21, 1986, a local alcoholic and petty criminal, darrell herrington, told police that he was with gordon randy steidl and herbert r. He became a believer that steidl, and his codefendant, herb whitlock, were innocent.
His story can be read in his newly released book, too politically sensitive. Both are convicted in 1987 primarily on the testimony of an individual known as the. Randy steidl and herb whitlock were wrongfully arrested for murder of dyke and karen rhodes, in a small town of paris, illinois. In 2009 he published a book about the case, too politically sensitive. Whitlock is free man after two decades in prison for paris, ill. Apr 14, 2011 steidl was accused and convicted of the brutal killings along with herb whitlock. Jan 09, 2008 herb whitlock, left, walks out of the edgar county jail tuesday, jan. After 26andahalf years, im pleased that this is concluded, steidl said.
The following year, gordon randy steidl and herbert r. This book describes how two white men from southern illinois, randy steidl and herb whitlock, were wrongly convicted of a double murder. Death row inmates tell their stories in new book duration. Two days later, all of a sudden randy steidl and herb whitlock became the two new suspects, callahan said. The settlement ends the last of the lawsuits filed by steidl and codefendant herb whitlock. Whitlock is free man after two decades in prison for paris. Whitlock previously settled a similar lawsuit for an undisclosed amount.
See how a persistent cop fought the system to for an innocent mans. Had protess taken the more appealing case of steidl instead, the history of the death penalty might have been different. In 1987, herbert whitlock and randy steidl were arrested and convicted, based on the testimony of deborah reinbolt and darrell herrington. Since when is any crime too politically sensitive to search for the truth. Jul 18, 2015 cop saves innocent man from death sentence. New theory on paris murders emerges from netherworld. Former death row inmate presents tale of missteps by police. Steidl was sentenced to death, whitlock to life in prison. Join investigating innocence and 170 supporters today. Callahan is author of the 2009 true crime book, since when is murder.
While randy steidl was convicted on both murder counts, herb was convicted of only killing karen. Investigating innocence needs your help with illinois attorney general and governor quinn. It revolves around the murders of dyke and karen rhoads, the conviction of herb whitlock and randy steidl during trials at the vermilion county courthouse, and their release years later. Exonerated death row survivor randy steidl speaks out. Our chicagobased civil rights lawyers have a proven track record of results, and have obtained. Whats different about this book is that is it written by a retired lieutenant in the illinois state police who participated in the criminal investigation, not by a defense attorney or by an exonerated. Former isp commanders book explores rhoads case news jg. Exdeath row inmate crusades against fatal flaws in system. The police eventually focus on local men randy steidl and herbert whitlock. February 1987 herb whitlock and randy steidl arrested and charged with murders of dyke and karen rhoads may 22, 1987 jury finds herb whitlock guilty in karen rhoads death and sentences him to.
1291 326 32 1453 202 1105 953 960 1073 1126 255 868 126 1390 1098 358 1227 1039 601 293 1410 30 1075 438 870 1128 1164 1232 887 1343 1185 915 691 1112 34